lots of places off the beaten track as well as som better known ones..
Ciao rtmgigem,
Congrats on the upcoming anniversary, you will have a lovely time spending it in Tuscany and Castellina in Chianti is a great central location from which to visit the smaller towns/villages that you've likely not seen yet.
May will be a great time, actually there is lots of flowering and green to be seen at the moment and you'll see more of that in May as the weather is also pretty nice.
I assume you will have a car so you will be able to get around easily to the small towns.... as you've seen on the site, we highly recommend Siena. It is a city but somehow with its closed off center and medieval look, the feeling is of being in a small town where time has stopped.
So I recommend Siena but other places in the vicinity you will have to explore include:
Castellina, Radda in Chianti, Panzano, Monteriggioni, Colle Val d'Elsa, the small castle at Staggia (it is very close to Castellina), San Gimignano, a day trip to Volterra, another to the Abbey at San Galgano, Certaldo, San Gimignano, San Miniato. Have you been to Pisa and Lucca? Have you already booked the two weeks at one place? Because an option would be to spend a week there, then move toward the coast for the second week. That way you can explore the coastal area, from Piombino to Livorno. Bolgheri, Castagneto Carducci, Rosignano.... maybe even Elba! May is still a bit cold as far as the temps of the sea so bathing is up to what you're used to.... but at least for Elba, it is the border between low season and high season which makes it the perfect time to explore the island.
I hope some of these suggestions just get you thinking.... there are so many off the beaten track but very lovely to discover. You can mix some of the more visited (such as San Gimignano) in with the smaller ones. You won't be bored and am sure you'll have a memorable anniversary vacation!!
Let me know if you want more suggestions
